How much should I charge for a pumpkin pie?
Updated ·
Charge about $36.39 per pie. At US average grocery prices (October 2026), one pie costs $7.02 in ingredients. Add packaging, your time at $15.00 an hour and 10% overhead and the full cost is $25.47. A 30% profit margin then gives $36.39.
What it costs to make a pumpkin pie today
This is one 9-inch pumpkin pie with an all-butter crust, filled from a 15-ounce can of pumpkin and a 12-ounce can of evaporated milk, priced at this month's US average prices: the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics monthly average for staples such as flour, butter, eggs, sugar and milk, and typical US grocery prices for the rest.
| Ingredient | Amount | Price used | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| All-Purpose Flour | 160 g | $0.54 per lb | $0.19 |
| Butter | 113 g | $3.98 per lb | $0.99 |
| Salt | 3 g | $0.07 per oz | $0.01 |
| Granulated Sugar | 6 g | $1.00 per lb | $0.01 |
| Water | 60 ml | $0.00 per ml | $0.00 |
| Pumpkin Puree | 425 g | $0.18 per oz | $2.70 |
| Evaporated Milk | 340 g | $0.18 per oz | $2.16 |
| Eggs | 2 | $2.32 per dozen | $0.39 |
| Granulated Sugar | 150 g | $1.00 per lb | $0.33 |
| Cinnamon | 3 g | $0.80 per oz | $0.08 |
| Ground Ginger | 1 g | $1.30 per oz | $0.05 |
| Ground Clove | 0.25 tsp | $0.27 per tsp | $0.07 |
| Nutmeg | 0.5 g | $2.10 per oz | $0.04 |
| Salt | 2 g | $0.07 per oz | $0.00 |
| Batch of 1 | $7.02 |
Pumpkin Puree is the biggest cost. See the pumpkin puree price and the evaporated milk price for how it has moved.
The price formula, with these numbers
- Ingredients: $7.02 for a batch of 1 (table above).
- Packaging: $2.50 × 1 = $2.50.
- Your time: 60 minutes × $15.00 an hour ÷ 60 = $15.00.
- Overhead: 10% of ingredients and packaging for electricity, gas, equipment and fees = $0.95.
- Cost per pie: $25.47 ÷ 1 = $25.47.
- Price: $25.47 ÷ (1 − 0.3) = $36.39 per pie.
Assumptions: $2.50 for a disposable 9-inch pie tin and a pie box, 60 minutes of hands-on time per pie (crust, filling, crimping and baking checks), $15.00 an hour, 10% overhead, 30% margin. They are a starting point: put your own in the calculator.
What a pumpkin pie sells for
Prices vary a lot by town, size and decoration. US figures and posted prices from bakeries around the US:
- $15 to $25 a pie, median $21 whole pumpkin pies listed by six home bakers. Source: Homegrown, how much to sell pumpkin pie for (prices read Oct 1, 2026).
- $25 a pie ($30 pecan) apple, sweet potato, coconut and lemon meringue pies, New Orleans, Louisiana. Source: Tasty Sweets and Cakes price list (seen Nov 17, 2026).
- $40 a pie seasonal apple and pumpkin pies from a cottage bakery in Washington, DC. Source: Bake Snail menu (seen Nov 17, 2026).
Check what bakers near you charge for the same size and quality before you settle on a price.
Getting the price right
- Bake several pies at once. The crust work goes faster in a batch and your time per pie drops.
- Nut and fruit pies cost more to make than pumpkin. Price each kind on its own instead of one price for every pie.
- Take holiday orders early with a pickup day. You can buy ingredients for the whole batch and nothing goes to waste.
Price your own pies
The calculator below already holds this recipe and the assumptions above. Change the prices to what you pay, set your batch size, time and margin, and it updates as you type. It runs in your browser, needs no account, and you can share or print the result.
Frequently asked questions
How much should I charge for a pumpkin pie?
Charge about $36.39 per pie. At US average grocery prices (October 2026), one pie costs $7.02 in ingredients. Add packaging, your time at $15.00 an hour and 10% overhead and the full cost is $25.47. A 30% profit margin then gives $36.39.
How much does a pumpkin pie cost to make?
$7.02 per pie in ingredients for the recipe on this page (1 pie per batch at October 2026 US average prices). Your own cost depends on what you pay, your recipe and how long it takes you: change any of these in the calculator.
What is the formula for pricing baked goods?
Price = cost per item ÷ (1 − profit margin). Cost per item is ingredients + packaging + your time + overhead for one batch, divided by the number of items. Here that is $25.47 ÷ 0.7 = $36.39 per pie.
What is the most expensive ingredient in a pumpkin pie?
Pumpkin Puree: $2.70 of the $7.02 batch (38%). When its price moves, your cost moves with it.
What to charge for other bakes
- Cookies (per dozen) about $17.52 a dozen
- Cupcakes about $4.40 per cupcake
- Sourdough bread (per loaf) about $13.00 per loaf
- Cinnamon rolls about $3.76 per roll
- Cake (per serving) about $4.93 per serving
- Brownies about $2.00 per brownie
- Cake pops about $2.42 per cake pop
- Macarons about $3.09 per macaron
- Banana bread (per loaf) about $16.12 per loaf
More: how to price baked goods, what recipes cost to make, ingredient prices.